Skepsis Insights

Every requirement in bioskepsis-insights-user-requirements-v1.1.md, with the verdict the document’s own rules force. No requirement now carries the verdict BLOCKED. Each row carries both halves of its account, what is buildable and what is still held, and names the decisions that released it. A requirement answered the other way is DROPPED, and that is the one verdict nobody can go and change.

Showing the 3 requirements that NP-05 released. A requirement that the document alone would have held is here because a decision with a date let it through.

ID	Verdict	Basis	What that means
`FR-PROF-03`	BUILD	research	All of it. OQ-18 names the core set that is required: name, affiliation, specialty, topic signal summary, fit score, papers and trials. Everything else is optional and shown when available. The completion score is visible to the customer and to the expert, and no scoring or sorting rule may read it (NP-06): it exists to motivate an expert to fill their profile, and a completion score that moved rank would be a ranking of who filled in a form. Still held. Nothing. Two exclusions are permanent rather than pending: no conflict-of-interest field, flag or note anywhere (NP-09), and no payment, claims or prescribing data (OQ-28). A field fed by a paid source would need its own decision, a written licence and a visible source label (NP-05); none is licensed at launch. Released by OQ-18, NP-05, NP-06, NP-09.
`FR-PROF-05`	BUILD	research	All of it, on open identifiers: ORCID researcher IDs, OpenAlex author IDs and US NPI provider numbers, plus each customer's own CRM IDs held in a per-customer mapping table (OQ-20). Identity resolution is built on those, and EFEVRE licenses no doctor reference database, so there is no third-party identifier to reconcile and no licence term to honour on a field. Still held. Nothing. A paid identifier source later needs its own decision, a written licence and a source label on every field that uses it (NP-05). Released by OQ-20, NP-05.
`FR-INT-05`	BUILD	research	All of it, and at launch it has nothing to do, which is the point: the answers license no outside data. Identity resolution runs on ORCID, OpenAlex and NPI, which are free to use, plus each customer's own CRM IDs (OQ-20), and no doctor reference database is licensed; FD-01 decides the same for enrolment data. What this requirement builds is the source register: every field carries a source label, shown on the profile and in exports, and a paid source added later needs its own decision and a written licence before a single field may use it (NP-05). Still held. Nothing. Released by OQ-20, NP-05, FD-01.

Requirements